That enormous profits should have turned into still more colossal losses, that new theories should have been developed and later discredited, that unlimited optimism should have been succeeded by the deepest despair, are all in strict accord with age-old tradition. Benjamin Graham A trading philosophy is something that cannot just be transferred from one person to another; it’s something that you have to acquire yourself through time and effort. Richard Driehaus The essential element is that the markets are ultimately based on human psychology, and by charting the markets you’re merely converting human psychology into graphic representations. I believe that the human mind is more powerful than any computer in analyzing the implications of these price graphs. Al Weiss Opportunities change, strategies change, but people and psychology do not change. If trend-following systems don’t work well, something else will. There’s always money being lost, so someone out there has to win. Gil Blake, New Market Wizards |
Archives of “human psychology” tag
rssThe Psychology Of Speculation – The Disconcerting Effect Of Sudden Losses And Gains
Time for another classic trading book excerpt. It is about limiting losses and ultimately becoming a better trader if you are willing to embark on that never ending journey to better understand yourself. James L. Fraser from Fraser Publishing clearly understood that. The introduction he wrote clearly shows his deep understanding of human psychology, trading and speculation. Human behavior never changes. That’s why I am a huge fan of old classics. Buy those books. Read them. Apply the wisdom imparted.
Henry Howard Harper: ‘The Psychology of Speculation – The Human Element in Stock Market Transactions’
Introduction
First privately printed by the author in 1926 and only found in secondhand stores at rare intervals this classic deserves a more wide spread audience. Harper’s human behavior material gives us insights into the handicapping prejudices that ruin our stock market theories and sound resolutions. Especially in our computer oriented age does the average investor seem incapable of calm reasoning , with the result that he often does precisely the opposite of what he had intended doing.
Moreover, Harper’s easy writing style clearly shows you how the correct ideas of theory are turned into the wrong formulas of practice, and how tickeritis, though mentally intoxicating, leads on to poverty. In a contrary way, we seldom see the favorite caprice of the stock market which is to violate precedent, and do the thing least expected of it. You had better believe it for there are no certainties in this investment world, and where you have no certainties, you should begin by understanding yourself.
James L. Fraser
Wells,Vermont
The Disconcerting Effect of Sudden Losses and Gains, page 17 – 19
There are but few things more unbalancing to the mind than the act of suddenly winning or losing large sums of money. A few years ago at Monte Carlo I was in company with a friend, a well known man of affairs who while there played at roulette nearly every day, merely as pastime. He was of mature age, naturally methodical, conservative, temperate and cool-headed. He made it an unalterable rule to limit his losses to $200 at any one sitting, and on losing his amount he always stopped playing. His bets were usually limited to two dollars on the numbers, and never doubled except for one turn of the wheel when his number won. He generally played three numbers at a time; never more than four. For ten consecutive sittings luck was against him and each time he had lost his stake of $200. I saw him get up and leave the room, apparently in a state of disgust. An hour or so later I discovered him at a roulette table in another room stacking his chips in piles on a dozen or more numbers. Now and again when he exceeded the limit the watchful croupier reduced his bets and pushed a few disks back to him. In addition to betting on the numbers he was staking a thousand franc note on one of the three columns, another thousand on the colors, and a like amount on the center dozen. In one run he lost seventeen consecutive bets on red, of a thousand franc each. His eyes were bloodshot, his fingers twitched, and plainly he was under the strain of great agitation. He continued to play for three hours or so, when all of a sudden he got up, stood for a moment looking dazedly about, then left the table. He afterwards told me that he lost twenty thousand dollars; and that he hadn’t the slightest recollection of anything that happened during the play, nor did he realize the amount he was betting. In this connection, it is a fact not generally known, that many rich men sing printed cards of instructions to the proprietor of a certain well known gambling club in the South, directing him to stop their play and refuse them further credit beyond a certain specified sum on any one day or evening of play, and refusing to become responsible beyond that amount. If men who trade in the stock market were to impose like restrictions upon their transactions the losses would in many cases be greatly minimized.
17 Points for Traders
- Patient with winners, and impatient with losers
- Making money more important than being right
- View TA as a picture of where traders are lining up to buy and sell
- Before they enter every trade they will know their profit target and/or stop exit
- Approach trade no.5 with the same conviction as the previous 4 losing trades
- Use naked charts
- Comfortable making decisions with incomplete information
- Do not think of markets as expensive or cheap
- Aggressive with trade size when doing well and modest when not
- Realize the market will be open tomorrow
- Judge their trading success on anything but money (more…)
Thoughts on Human Nature and Speculation – Humphrey B. Neil
The chapter entitled, “More Thoughts on Human Nature and Speculation”, includes some classic thinking on aspects of human psychology which prevent us from operating profitably in the markets. A passage from Neil on the dangers of greed follows this line of thought:
“…I have watched traders in brokers’ offices with deep interest, and have tried to learn the traits that crippled their profits. The desire to “make a killing”—greed—has impressed me particularly.
Perhaps this desire to squeeze the last point out of a trade is the most difficult to fight against. It is also the most dangerous. How often has it happened in your own case that you have entered a commitment with a conservatively set goal, which your judgment has told you was reasonable, only to throw over your resolutions when your stock has reached that point, because you thought “there were four more points in the move?”
The irony of it is that seemingly nine times out of ten (I know, for it has happened with me) the stock does not reach your hoped-for objective; then—to add humiliation to lost profits—it goes against you for another number of points; and, like as not, you end up with no profit at all, or a loss.
Maybe it would help you if I told you what I have done to keep me in my traces: I have opened a simple set of books, just as if I were operating with money belonging to someone else. I have set down what would be considered a fair return on speculative capital, and have opened an account for losses as well as for gains, knowing that the real secret of speculative success lies in taking losses quickly when I think my judgment has been wrong.
When a commitment is earning fair profits, and is acting as I had judged it should act, I let my profits run. But, so soon as I think that my opinion has been erroneous, I endeavor to get out quickly and not to allow my greed to force me to hold for those ephemeral, hoped-for points. Nor do I allow my pride to prevent an admission of error. I had rather, by far, accept the fact that I have been wrong than accept large losses…”
This looks like worthwhile study material, so read on and don’t mind the fact that most of the references date back to 1930. Time honored wisdom is the best, and sound practices are applicable in any age.
Trading Tactics
Gerald Loeb was a highly successful trader who wrote the classics “The Battle For Investment Survival” and “The Battle For Stock Market Profits.” Although they’ve been around for as long as I’ve been alive, you may find them helpful in today’s market.
Once in a while I take time to review old handwritten notes I’ve taken from the books I’ve read in the past including from Loeb. These notes often serve as inspiration to my own trading. Even though I’ve read them many times over the years, they always offer a good insight.
Loeb’s Trading Tactics:
- The market is a battlefield. Make sure you are on the winning side
- You must trade with the actions of the market and not simply by how you might think the market should trade
- Knowledge through experience is one trait that separates successful stock market speculators from everyone else
- To do well in short-term trading, it takes full-time attention and dedication
- Exploit all new trends quickly and aggressively
- The best traders are usually psychologists. The worst are usually accountants (more…)
20 Habits of Wealthy Traders
1) Patient with winners and impatient with losers
2) Making money is more important than being right
3) View Tech Analysis as a picture of where traders are lining up to buy and sell
4) Before they enter every trade they will know profit target or stop exit
5) Approach trade no.5 with the same conviction as the previous 4 losing trades
6) Use naked charts
a) As we mature we begin peeling off indicators
b) Prices action is key
7) Comfortable making decisions with incomplete information
8) Stopped trying to pick tops & bottoms long ago
a) They make their money in the meat/middle of a trend (wait for confirmation)
b) A trend is much more likely to continue than it is to reverse
9) Do not think of the market as expensive or cheap
a) Ignore whether you think something is overpriced or understand, think price action
10) Aggressive with trade size when doing well or modest when not
a) Do more of what is making, less of what is not
11) Realised that the market will be open tomorrow (more…)
The Psychology Of Speculation – The Disconcerting Effect Of Sudden Losses And Gains
Time for another classic trading book excerpt. The subject is similar to the one in yesterday’s post. It is about limiting losses and ultimately becoming a better trader if you are willing to embark on that never ending journey to better understand yourself. James L. Fraser from Fraser Publishing clearly understood that. The introduction he wrote clearly shows his deep understanding of human psychology, trading and speculation. Human behavior never changes. That’s why I am a huge fan of old classics. Buy those books. Read them. Apply the wisdom imparted.
Henry Howard Harper: ‘The Psychology of Speculation – The Human Element in Stock Market Transactions’
Introduction
First privately printed by the author in 1926 and only found in secondhand stores at rare intervals this classic deserves a more wide spread audience. Harper’s human behavior material gives us insights into the handicapping prejudices that ruin our stock market theories and sound resolutions. Especially in our computer oriented age does the average investor seem incapable of calm reasoning , with the result that he often does precisely the opposite of what he had intended doing.
Moreover, Harper’s easy writing style clearly shows you how the correct ideas of theory are turned into the wrong formulas of practice, and how tickeritis, though mentally intoxicating, leads on to poverty. In a contrary way, we seldom see the favorite caprice of the stock market which is to violate precedent, and do the thing least expected of it. You had better believe it for there are no certainties in this investment world, and where you have no certainties, you should begin by understanding yourself. (more…)
Jack Schwager :Risk & Reward
“In one experiment, subjects were given a hypothetical choice between a sure $3,000 gain versus an 80 percent chance of a $4,000 gain and a 20 percent chance of not getting anything. The vast majority of people preferred the sure $3000 gain, even though the other alternative had a higher expected gain (0.80 X $4,000 = $3,200). Then they flipped the question around and gave people a choice between a certain loss of $3,000 versus an 80 percent chance of losing $4,000 and a 20 percent chance of not losing anything. In this case, the vast majority chose to gamble and take the 80 percent chance of a $4,000 loss, even though the expected loss would be $3,200.
In both cases, people made irrational choices because they selected the alternative with the worse expected gain or greater expected loss. Why? Because the experiment reflects a quirk in human behavior in regards to risk and gain: people are risk averse when it comes to gains, but risk takers when it comes to avoiding a loss. And this relates very much to trading. It is exactly the quirk in human psychology that causes people to let their losses run and cut their profits short. So the old cliché of let your profits run and cut your losses short is actually the exact opposite of what human nature tends to do.”
The Psychology Of Speculation – The Disconcerting Effect Of Sudden Losses And Gains
Time for another classic trading book excerpt. The subject is similar to the one in yesterday’s post. It is about limiting losses and ultimately becoming a better trader if you are willing to embark on that never ending journey to better understand yourself. James L. Fraser from Fraser Publishing clearly understood that. The introduction he wrote clearly shows his deep understanding of humanpsychology, trading and speculation. Human behavior never changes. That’s why I am a huge fan of old classics. Buy those books. Read them. Apply the wisdom imparted.
Henry Howard Harper: ‘The Psychology of Speculation – The Human Element in Stock Market Transactions’
Introduction
First privately printed by the author in 1926 and only found in secondhand stores at rare intervals this classic deserves a more wide spread audience. Harper’s human behavior material gives us insights into the handicapping prejudices that ruin our stock market theories and sound resolutions. Especially in our computer oriented age does the average investor seem incapable of calm reasoning , with the result that he often does precisely the opposite of what he had intended doing.
Moreover, Harper’s easy writing style clearly shows you how the correct ideas of theory are turned into the wrong formulas of practice, and how tickeritis, though mentally intoxicating, leads on to poverty. In a contrary way, we seldom see the favorite caprice of the stock market which is to violate precedent, and do the thing least expected of it. You had better believe it for there are no certainties in this investment world, and where you have no certainties, you should begin by understanding yourself.
James L. Fraser (more…)