rss

Hong Kong formally withdraws extradition bill

The Hong Kong government formally withdrew a controversial extradition bill on Wednesday, following months of social unrest and political turmoil that have upended the city’s normally peaceful image.

The secretary for security, John Lee Ka-chiu, made the announcement before lawmakers in the chamber of the Legislative Council. The move meets one of the five demands by anti-government demonstrators, who are also calling for the resignation of Chief Executive Carrie Lam.

Lee’s announcement was met with shouts from pro-democracy lawmakers. Civic Party member Kwok Ka-ki was expelled after calling for Lee’s resignation while Lee was still addressing the chamber. Other pro-democracy lawmakers held up slogans reading, “Lee Ka-chiu step down.”

Meanwhile, the Hong Kong man whose alleged killing of his girlfriend in Taiwan prompted the crisis over the bill on Wednesday was released from prison on a lesser offense of money laundering. The suspect, Chan Tong-kai, has said that he would turn himself in to Taiwanese authorities.

The move to introduce the bill earlier this year was prompted by a legal dilemma over the murder suspect because the governments of Hong Kong and Taiwan do not have an extradition treaty. Chan was originally sentenced to 29 months in prison in Hong Kong but was released after serving 18 months.

The Hong Kong government had said the legal loophole needed to be closed to uphold justice and align the city’s laws with international standards. But the proposed law would also have paved the way for criminal suspects to be sent to mainland China, which many say lacks an independent judiciary system.

Chan Tong-kai, a Hong Kong citizen who was accused of murdering his girlfriend in Taiwan last year, leaves from Pik Uk Prison in Hong Kong on Oct. 23.   © Reuters

Widespread peaceful demonstrations against the bill drew millions of people to the streets in early June. Opponents of the legislation said at the time that the proposed law could have been used by mainland authorities to extradite anyone in Hong Kong to China, including Beijing’s political adversaries.

Over the past few months, protests have devolved into widespread anti-government and anti-China demonstrations, with many calling for a more democratic society and greater accountability to its citizens.

Police have used tear gas, rubber bullets, water cannons and sponge grenades to disperse crowds, as some hard-line protesters have set fires at rail stations, smashed store fronts and vandalized other places of business with connections to mainland China or those perceived to be against the protests.

On Oct. 1 — the day Beijing held ceremonies to commemorate the 70th anniversary of the founding of the People’s Republic of China — a policeman shot an 18-year-old man while he was attacking officers. That marked the first time a demonstrator was hit by live ammunition since the protests began.

As violent clashes between protesters and police continued into autumn, Lam invoked emergency powers on Oct. 4 to ban the wearing of face masks during demonstrations. But tens of thousands of protesters have defied the ban to hide their identity and protect themselves against tear gas.

Hong Kong leader Lam says cannot say under what circumstances she’d call on China central government

Hong Kong leader Carrie Lam comments from press conference.

  • says there is no bottom line for protesters’ violent acts
  • says amount of visitors during ‘golden week’ fell by 50%
  • appeals to developers and landlords to offer relief to retailers
  • says aims for fair district elections, although current atmosphere is complex
  • says an objective of the anti-mask law is to let youth know not to participate in these political actions
  • she has no plans to use the emergency regulation ordnance for introduction of other laws
  • it is still too early to say if the anti-mask law is ineffective
  • using the emergency powers was a very difficult decision
  • anti-mask law still valid and effective at this time
  • upcoming policy address will not be the “usual comprehensive” address
  • says there is widespread support for the anti-mask law
  • says no foreign government should think these are peaceful protests
  • says believes Q3 economic figures will surely be very bad
  • she did not meet any central govt officials to talk about business while in Beijing for national day holiday
  • says she still feels HK should find solutions on its own, and central govt holds same view
  •  says cannot say under what circumstances Hong Kong would call on central govt

The HKD is on the weak side, but not threatening the band as yet:

Hong Kong leader Carrie Lam comments from press conference. 

Hong Kong chief executive to withdraw extradition bill: reports

Hong Kong Chief Executive Carrie Lam will formally withdraw a controversial extradition bill, which has been at the center of massive demonstrations this summer and is one of protesters’ five demands, multiple local media reported on Wednesday.

The South China Morning Post said that Lam will meet with pro-establishment allies on Wednesday afternoon at her official residence. Citing sources, the SCMP said that all 43 pro-establishment lawmakers on Tuesday night had been invited to meet with Lam.

Formal withdrawal of the legislation is one of five demands made by protesters. The others are Lam’s resignation and introduction of universal suffrage, rescinding the characterization of protesters as rioters, unconditional release of arrested demonstrators, and creation of an independent commission to investigate complaints of excessive use of force by the police.

While acceding to one demand would be viewed as an olive branch by Lam, protesters have said that they would not settle for anything less than the agreement of all five.

Michael Tien Puk-sun, a pro-Beijing lawmaker in Hong Kong’s Legislative Council, told reporters on Wednesday that the withdrawal of the bill would not be enough and “comes too late” to resolve the monthslong standoff. (more…)